• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Akram Law

Calgary Criminal Defence Lawyer

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Services
    • Calgary Assault Lawyer
    • Calgary Sexual Assault Lawyer
    • Calgary Bail Hearing Lawyer
    • Calgary Theft & Fraud Offences Lawyer
    • Calgary Drug Offence Lawyer
    • Calgary Impaired Driving Lawyer
  • Get Started
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Criminal Law

Can a Criminal Case Be Dismissed for Court Delay in 2026?

Khalid Akram · November 5, 2026 ·

Court Delay

Can Criminal Charges Be Dismissed Because of Court Delays in Calgary?

Yes. A criminal case in Calgary can still be stopped because of unreasonable court delays. However, Canada’s 2026 Criminal Code amendments have changed how courts assess certain delay applications and whether ending the prosecution is the appropriate remedy.

Section 11(b) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms gives everyone charged with a crime the right to be tried within a reasonable period of time.

In R. v. Jordan, the Supreme Court of Canada set out time periods for most criminal trials. Once the relevant period is exceeded, the delay is presumed to be unreasonable unless the Crown is able to show exceptional circumstances.

The accused may seek a stay of proceedings if his right to a speedy trial is infringed.

A stay puts an end to the criminal proceedings without a conclusion on guilt or innocence of the accused person. This remedy is not the same as an acquittal after trial.

Judicial stay used to be the remedy in place for a proven infringement of the right to a speedy trial under Jordan.

The amendments made in 2026 will make it necessary for the courts to examine the possibility of applying another remedy in situations where this new legislation applies.

It means that once the regular deadline for the trial is exceeded, the criminal proceedings are not necessarily going to be stayed.

What Changed Under Canada’s New 2026 Court Delay Laws?

Bill C-16, the Protecting Victims Act, received Royal Assent on June 18, 2026. The relevant amendments came into force on July 18, 2026.

The legislation introduced Part XV.1 of the Criminal Code, establishing additional rules for assessing unreasonable delays and deciding what remedy should follow.

An important limitation is that these new provisions apply only to offences committed on or after July 18, 2026.

If the alleged offence occurred before that date, the new Part XV.1 does not apply merely because the case remains before a Calgary court in 2026 or later.

Courts Must Consider Alternatives to Staying Criminal Charges

Section 492.31 of the Criminal Code states that courts must not order a stay for unreasonable delay unless satisfied that no other remedy would be appropriate and just in the circumstances.

When making that determination, judges must consider:

  • The stage of the criminal proceedings.
  • The impact a stay would likely have on the victim.
  • The prejudice caused or likely to be caused to the accused.
  • Public confidence in the administration of justice.
  • Society’s interest in having criminal allegations decided on their merits.

For instance, an accused of assault charges in Calgary might petition to stay the prosecution due to unreasonable delay.

If the court determines that there is unreasonable delay, the new provision will direct the court to consider if another remedy would be an appropriate remedy for the violation.

This is because the law does not specify an alternative remedy for each situation. This will depend on the circumstances and jurisdiction of the court.

The constitutional right of the accused to a trial within a reasonable time will still be protected. The new restrictions under the statute should be consistent with the Charter.

Complex Criminal Cases May Justify Additional Time

These sections further provide that in determining the complexity of a particular case, the court should take into account certain elements.

According to section 492.26, the court should look at the elements that contribute to the complexity of the case, which include the number of applications or motions, separate hearing dates, adjournments and the time to make decisions on procedural matters.

This may come into play in Calgary where there is a case with more than one accused person, voluminous electronic evidence or multiple pre-trial applications.

Just because the Crown says that a case is serious or there have been many adjournments, it does not mean that the case is complex.

Victims Must Be Informed About Delay Applications

The 2026 changes also cover the notification of the victim.

According to section 492.25, the prosecution is required to make reasonable efforts to notify the victim about filing for unreasonable delay and about the decision made by the court regarding this matter.

How Long Can a Criminal Case Take in Calgary Under the Jordan Rules?

The 2026 legislation did not replace the established 18-month and 30-month Jordan ceilings.

The applicable timeline generally depends on where the case is being tried and whether a preliminary inquiry took place.

Calgary Criminal Court Presumptive Delay Ceiling
Alberta Court of Justice 18 months
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta 30 months
Provincial court trial following a preliminary inquiry 30 months

How Is Criminal Court Delay Calculated?

It is not true that each month between the charge date and the trial date falls within the Jordan ceiling applicable to that case.

The court has to identify which months are for the defence and which are justified by exceptional circumstances.

Here is a hypothetical Calgary case:

Someone is charged with assault, and the estimated time to finish their trial is 21 months since the day they were charged.

In the course of the trial, the defence made a request for an adjournment resulting in two months of delay.

If these two months are correctly attributed to the defence, then the remaining delay is 19 months.

This exceeds the ceiling of 18 months for an ordinary trial at Alberta Court of Justice.

Thus, the accused might have reason to consider the delay presumptively unreasonable.

For an offence committed on or after July 18, 2026, one should take into account new statutory provisions regarding unreasonable delay.

Which Delays May Be Excluded?

Delay caused due to the defence or a valid waiver of delay usually does not count towards the Jordan limit.

Such delay may include the request made by the accused for adjournments, lack of availability of the defence counsel, among others.

However, making requests for disclosure or any other form of challenge to the admissibility of evidence or bringing an application under the Charter does not necessarily imply that the accused is causing delay.

This is because the reasons for the adjournments should be analysed by the courts.

Exceptional circumstances beyond the control of the Crown may also justify certain delays.

Regular congestion in the court or shortage of resources in the court alone does not amount to an exceptional circumstance.

Can Charges Be Stayed Before 18 or 30 Months?

Yes, although these applications are uncommon.

Where the accused is asking for relief below the presumptive ceiling, he or she would need to show that there were some genuine efforts made to push the process along and that the process was unnecessarily taking more time than it should have.

This would be considered a mere inconvenience.

It would take into account the circumstances of the prosecution and the complexity of the matter.

How Do the 2026 Supreme Court Decisions Affect Criminal Cases in Calgary?

Two important Supreme Court of Canada decisions, with written reasons released on May 29, 2026, clarified how exceptional circumstances can affect the Jordan analysis.

Although these cases originated outside Alberta, Supreme Court decisions establish principles that Calgary courts must follow.

R. v. Vrbanic — Complex Cases and Scheduling Errors

In R. v. Vrbanic, 2026 SCC 19, the Supreme Court considered a large drug prosecution involving multiple accused persons, extensive evidence and complicated pretrial proceedings.

Some of the accused were granted dates for their trials beyond the normal limit of 18 months due to a scheduling error involving their expected participation in the application process.

The court pointed out that the complexity exception test consists of determining whether the case in question was complex, whether the Crown took reasonable steps to minimize delay, and whether complexity warranted the extra time.

This judgment shows that a Crown scheduling error is not an absolute bar to making the complexity exception argument.

Nonetheless, the Crown will still have to show that there are good reasons for the delay.

R. v. Jacques-Taylor — Delays in Joint Criminal Trials

In R. v. Jacques-Taylor, 2026 SCC 20, the Supreme Court considered delays arising from scheduling conflicts between defence lawyers in a joint criminal trial.

The Court ruled that some scheduling conflicts that exist between co-accused individuals may fall under exceptional circumstances.

Some factors that can be considered include whether the joint trial is in the interest of justice, whether the delay was caused by the joint trial, whether the delay was reasonably unavoidable, and whether the Crown could reasonably have minimized it.

This decision may be important in Calgary where there are cases that involve multiple accused persons who are being tried jointly.

However, this decision does not imply that every scheduling conflict excuses the trial delay.

How Can You Apply to Have Criminal Charges Stayed for Unreasonable Delay in Calgary?

Review the History of the Criminal Case

The first step is identifying when the charges were laid and when the evidence and arguments at trial are expected to finish.

Relevant court records may include:

  • The original charging documents.
  • Court appearance and adjournment dates.
  • Crown disclosure records.
  • Trial scheduling correspondence.
  • Records of defence applications and motions.
  • Reasons for cancelled or rescheduled hearings.

The lawyer for the accused can compile a chronology of events for every interval.

This would make it easy to differentiate between delay due to institutional reasons and that which is caused by the defence.

The earlier stages of the prosecution may also be reviewed alongside what happens after a criminal charge is laid in Calgary.

Determine Which Legal Framework Applies

The significance of the time of the alleged offence is due to the transition period until 2026.

In case the offence was committed before July 18, 2026, then the new Part XV.1 does not apply.

In case the offence was committed after this date, then it is necessary to take into account both the Criminal Code and the Charter rights of the accused, and the Jordan jurisprudence.

It is important for the defence to determine whether the case can be regarded as one that is beyond the presumptive ceiling or an unreasonable delay under the ceiling is needed.

File the Charter Application

The criminal defence lawyer is in a position to prepare the application and supporting documents requesting the relief due to the delay that may be considered unreasonable.

A delay application may form part of the broader process of building a Charter challenge based on the circumstances of the case.

The Crown then gets a chance to react to the allegations raised by the defence lawyer.

The judge considers the evidence and arguments put forward by the two sides to establish if there was a violation of the right to be tried within a reasonable time.

Where the 2026 amendments are applicable, the issue of a possible alternative to a stay will need to be determined.

The raising of the issue of delay will not automatically result in the discharge of the case.

An Experienced Criminal Defence Lawyer can review the chronology of the case, identify which periods of delay may count toward the Jordan ceiling, and determine what legal framework applies to the alleged offence.

Calgary Auto Theft Charges Under Canada’s 2026 Bail Rules

Khalid Akram · October 12, 2026 ·

Calgary Auto Theft Charges Under 2026 Rules

Charges for auto theft in Calgary do not simply involve the theft of a vehicle. Based on the nature of the case, the investigation of charges may include motor vehicle theft, property obtained through crime, use of a vehicle without consent, possession of vehicle theft tools, organized auto theft, or other charges related to dangerous driving, weapon charges, property damage, or breaches of release terms.

This is important as it influences what the Crown will need to prove, what the possible defenses are, the bail provisions, and the potential sentence.

The 2026 Canadian reforms introduced certain provisions that could be applicable in cases involving serious motor vehicle thefts, especially those involving allegations of violence, criminal organizations, repeated violent offenses, and new offenses while on release from previous charges.

Not all cases of auto theft are considered reverse onus cases. It is crucial to match the Criminal Code provisions with the actual charge.

Understanding Auto Theft and Stolen Vehicle Charges

Motor vehicle theft and possession of a stolen vehicle are different allegations.

In a case of motor vehicle theft, the Crown must show that the accused took or converted the vehicle with the requisite mens rea. In a case of possession of a vehicle stolen by another, the Crown must show that all the legal elements of possession were met, including that the accused knew that the vehicle was stolen by someone else.

The mere fact that the accused was found in a stolen vehicle does not mean that the accused committed the theft of that vehicle. The Crown must show who drove the vehicle, who possessed the keys, who controlled the vehicle, when the vehicle was taken, what the accused knew, and whether the accused participated in taking the vehicle.

The passenger could be under investigation or charged with the crime, but being in the vehicle at that time would not be enough to prove all elements of theft or possession of the stolen goods.

It should be noted that in one incident a person may be charged with various crimes: dangerous driving, fleeing from the police, possession of instruments for breaking into vehicles, mischief, possession of weapons, breach of bail conditions, or membership in an organized crime group. Each allegation must be separately proven.

A Theft & Fraud Offences Lawyer should identify the exact section of the Criminal Code relied on by the Crown. This prevents an ordinary auto theft allegation from being treated as if it involved violence or organized crime when it does not.

How the 2026 Bail Rules Can Affect Auto Theft Charges

The changes in 2026 could have implications for bail in serious offences relating to theft of a motor vehicle. It is not automatic that if someone is charged with the theft of a car that they will be kept in custody or have the onus placed on them at the bail hearing.

The court would normally use the ordinary bail process except where there is a reverse-onus provision.

If there is a reverse onus, then the accused person must explain why they should not be detained and how their proposed plan for release addresses the court’s concerns.

The Crown could put forward concerns regarding public safety, compliance with court proceedings, recidivism, previous failures, other charges pending against the accused, violence, involvement with organized crime, or the behavior of the person who is under release.

The broader 2026 bail rules in Canada may therefore become relevant where the particular auto theft allegation falls within one of the amended provisions.

Conditions of release could be employed as risk management tools. The conditions could relate to geographic constraints, residing in a particular place, reporting, prohibited contact, tools associated with breaking into cars, or restricted zones.

Conditions are always legal commitments. A person who is freed based on an alleged auto theft must take care to read all the conditions and comply strictly. Breach allegations will result in arrest, new charges, loss of release, stringent conditions, or difficulty in securing future release on bail.

The rules surrounding judicial interim release and conditions may be important when determining what restrictions apply after release.

A realistic plan for release is essential at times. It can be made up of the accused’s actual address, place of work, mode of transport, supervision, a proper surety where applicable, and a plausible account of compliance with conditions.

An individual judgment by the court is still mandatory. An aggravated nature of the charge will have an effect on the assessment process, but it does not necessarily mean automatic detention.

Evidence and Defence Issues in Auto Theft Cases

Auto theft cases can depend on evidence that needs to be analyzed carefully. Police could use surveillance videos, license plate information, vehicle tracking, witness identification, dash-cam video, police observations, keys, vehicle programming equipment, cell phone evidence, fingerprint evidence, GPS information, and statements from the accused.

Surveillance video can be helpful, but it may not properly identify the individual in the video. Factors such as image quality, lighting, the position of the camera, how long the video runs, the clothing of the individual, and the time elapsed between the theft and the video could influence the value of identification evidence.

Where identification is disputed, the defence may need to consider issues involved in challenging eyewitness testimony alongside video and other evidence.

Vehicle tracking could reveal where the vehicle went or where it was found. It may not identify the driver at each location. The Crown should link the vehicle tracking information to the accused.

The accused in a case involving a stolen vehicle might deny awareness, control, or involvement. The defence might consider questions about who drove the vehicle, who had access to the keys, whether the accused was a passenger in the vehicle, when the vehicle was stolen, and whether there is any evidence of the accused’s state of mind.

Police statements could also be critical in these kinds of cases. The defence might look into the statements made to the police, how well the statement was documented, whether the accused had access to a lawyer, whether the statement was given voluntarily, and whether the accused’s Charter rights were respected.

Vehicles, residences, and cellphones can all be searched in these kinds of investigations, and although police will usually have some form of warrant, the parameters of the search would need to be examined. The rules governing search and seizure in Calgary criminal cases may therefore become relevant. Although the potential for Charter problems does not necessarily lead to the exclusion of evidence, it may become a factor in the overall defence strategy.

The essential question in the trial will be whether the Crown can prove each element of the charge beyond a reasonable doubt.

Sentencing and Legal Help for Calgary Auto Theft Charges

The penalty for auto theft depends on the exact nature of the crime, the facts, the value of the car, any damage done, whether there was violence or threats involved, whether there was an allegation of organized crime, the history of the defendant, and the mitigating evidence available.

A normal auto theft should not be assumed to have all the aggravating circumstances that would justify the special provisions for violent or criminal organization theft.

The aggravating circumstances include such things as violence, threats, organized crime, previous similar offences, offences committed when released from custody, substantial damage to property, planning, commission of multiple offences, and risk to the community.

The mitigating circumstances include such things as lack of previous record, guilty plea, acceptance of responsibility, treatment or rehabilitation efforts, employment, family responsibilities, restitution, and other personal circumstances of the case.

If the 2026 amendments are applicable in cases where there is violence, organized crime, or repeat violent offending in an auto theft case, the judge could place more emphasis on denunciation and deterrence or follow the guidelines for consecutive sentences.

The court may also need to consider the available sentencing options in a Calgary criminal conviction based on the specific offence and circumstances.

An experienced Calgary criminal lawyer will look at your situation in detail, attend the bail hearing, look at the prosecution’s case, handle identification and search issues, disclosure and negotiation of the case, and prepare for trial or sentencing.

The very first thing that you should ensure is that you do not make things even more difficult for yourself. Adhere to all conditions of release, do not comment publicly about your case, do not contact anyone who is restricted from contacting you, do not destroy any potential evidence, and never miss any court appearance.

Repeat Violent Offenders Canada 2026 Sentencing Rules

Khalid Akram · September 28, 2026 ·

2026 Sentencing Changes for Repeat Violent Offenders

The changes in Canada’s 2026 bail and sentencing reforms introduced new penalties for some individuals with previous violent convictions in case they get another violent sentence. The amendments do not impose a mandatory jail sentence or predetermined sentence for all individuals classified as repeat violent offenders. Rather, the new provisions call upon courts to take into account certain previous violent offending as an aggravating factor but at the same time consider the complete sentencing regime under the Criminal Code.

The Bail and Sentencing Reform Act was assented to on June 15, 2026. The majority of the bail and sentencing provisions will come into effect on July 15, 2026.

In case an individual in Calgary has to be sentenced, the main point is not only if this individual has a criminal record. The court should find out if the offence currently charged involved any violence, if previous conviction qualifies as per the test, if the conviction occurred within the prescribed period, and which sentence would be proportional in this case.

The New 2026 Rule for Repeat Violent Offending

The provisions of 2026 introduced an aggravating circumstance for qualifying repeat violent offending. Aggravating circumstances refer to facts that may justify a more severe punishment. However, such a circumstance alone does not determine the outcome; instead, the sentencing judge needs to consider it.

The new provision requires that the current crime includes violence, threat of violence, or an attempt at violence toward another individual, and that the offender has a qualifying conviction within the last five years of that nature.

Therefore, not all criminal history would fall within the new provision. If there is a past conviction that does not involve violence but, say, some property crime, then it cannot be included in the definition automatically. The judge will need to consider the specific character of the past offense instead of the general term “repeat offender.”

The phrasing also indicates that only one past qualifying conviction may be enough. One is not required to have many convictions for violence prior to the aggravating factor becoming applicable. Yet, having one past conviction for violence, together with a lengthy history of similar convictions, does not mean the same thing.

The five years are crucial. In determining the applicability of this aggravating factor, the court will look at the time when the past conviction was obtained, in order to decide whether it fits into the statutory period. If the past violent conviction is outside this period, then it will not satisfy this 2026 aggravating factor. It can remain relevant to the overall criminal record in certain situations, but cannot be considered as automatically satisfying this new aggravating factor.

Before considering these aggravating facts and convictions at sentencing, the Crown must establish both of them. Defence counsel has an opportunity to review all necessary documents.

The broader 2026 bail and sentencing reforms also introduced changes to bail rules, reverse-onus provisions and other sentencing considerations.

How Previous Violent Convictions Can Affect a Sentence

The presence of a criminal record may influence sentencing, but the court cannot just add up the number of convictions and impose a certain number of months or years in accordance with that. The judge needs to examine the criminal record in detail.

Recent conviction of the same type of violence may be considered as more relevant compared to the older unrelated conviction. In case there have been several convictions recently, it may be seen as the tendency of committing offences, but on the other hand a long gap in committing offences can give a different perspective. Moreover, it should be considered how the accused acted after the previous convictions; did he/she obeyed court orders or showed some signs of being rehabilitated.

For example, if the person has one recent conviction for violent offence, the court should take into account the new aggravating circumstance, as long as there is also the current offence of the violent nature. Yet, the judge has to assess the nature of both offenses.

Having several prior convictions for violent acts can make the Crown push for an increased sentence. The Crown can say that there needs to be more focus on the elements of denunciation and deterrence especially when previous sentences were unable to prevent future violent acts. It will then be up to the defence to argue about the particular record before the court, the accused, any steps towards rehabilitation, and other legal factors preventing excessive sentences.

In cases where the offender has a record containing both violent and non-violent convictions, careful consideration will be necessary. Not all prior convictions have equal legal importance in the case. The new aggravating factor concerning repeat-violence only applies to convictions that involve violence, threats of violence, or any act of violence done against another person. Other convictions can still play a role in the background of the case but should not be considered as qualifying violent convictions.

The main issue will be whether the Crown can show that the new rule applies and the weight that should be given to it in the entire sentencing process.

Sentencing Principles Still Apply in Calgary Courts

These changes in 2026 have neither stripped the judge of discretion nor substituted the well-established sentencing principles in Canada. The judge needs to apply the proportionate penalty depending on the nature of the crime committed by the offender.

Proportionality principle remains fundamental. While the serious violent crime might attract a harsh penalty, such penalty has to be based on the actual behavior, the consequences, the role played, and other facts. No severe penalties will be imposed just due to the public worry about the repeat offending.

The judges also take into consideration parity principle. When similar offenders commit similar offenses under similar conditions, then they ought to get similar sentences. It does not mean all the cases are treated alike but that a sentence should fit within the approach applied in other similar cases.

In relation to those offences for which there are consecutive sentences imposed upon a person, the issue of totality needs to be taken into account by the court. This means that the combination of the consecutive sentences should not become an overly harsh punishment. The newly proposed changes of 2026 may result in the need of the court to take into account the consecutive sentences in some cases; however, consecutive sentences of imprisonment are not automatic when it comes to repeat violent offences.

The court can take into account a number of sentencing purposes such as denunciation, deterrence, rehabilitation, protection of the public, reparation and responsibility. The importance of these purposes varies in different situations.

The issue of repeat violent offences makes denunciation and deterrence more important, while it does not mean that rehabilitation becomes irrelevant. Sentencing court can consider such factors as counselling, addiction treatment, mental health problems, employment, family situation, housing and other factors in order to find out reasons of the criminal’s behaviour or his future plans.

Guilty plea may also become a relevant factor, although its importance is determined by a number of circumstances such as timing, responsibility and influence on the witnesses.

Depending on the offence and circumstances, the court may also consider different sentencing options in a Calgary criminal conviction.

Preparing for Sentencing After a Violent Offence

The process of sentencing begins with the careful consideration of the true charge and the position of the Crown. The person who is subject to sentencing needs to know whether the Crown is relying on the new aggravating factor of repeat violence and which previous conviction is used.

Calgary criminal defence lawyers have the ability to review the criminal history of the accused and see whether the previously charged crime contains violence. The criminal defence counsel can look at the previous conviction to see whether it took place within five years and whether the Crown has enough evidence to use it.

The defence can provide some information about the accused to the court in order to present the complete picture. The information can range from the accused’s treatment, counseling sessions, letters of reference, employment, education, family, health and housing plans, and other actions done in order to prevent further offending.

A sentencing hearing is not a re-hearing of the original trial. Nevertheless, the factual findings of the Court may be of some significance. When there is a dispute between the prosecution and the defence as to the existence of an aggravating factor, the Court may have to resolve it in order for sentencing to take place.

The Court will also look at the range of sentences available, the maximum sentence for the offence, any mandatory provisions, as well as previous cases which deal with similar behavior. It must be tailored to the facts of the case rather than assume that all offenders with a history of violence will be punished similarly.

The 2026 amendments give more weight to the qualifying violent conviction in sentencing. These do not negate fairness, proportionality, and individualized sentencing. It takes a good sentencing stance to focus on the charges, the criminal history, the evidence, and the offender’s personal situation.

What Happens If a Witness Changes Their Story Before a Criminal Trial?

Khalid Akram · September 7, 2026 ·

What Happens When a Witness Changes Their Story Before a Criminal Trial?

A witness may give one version of events to police and later provide a different account. The change might involve a small detail, a major contradiction, or a complete reversal of an earlier allegation.

The effect on a criminal trial depends on what changed and how important that evidence is to the case.

A changed statement does not automatically make the original statement disappear. It also does not automatically prove that either version is false. Lawyers may need to compare the accounts, consider any explanation for the differences, and examine other available evidence.

Does Changing a Statement Automatically End the Criminal Case?

No. A witness changing their statement does not automatically cause criminal charges to be withdrawn or dismissed.

The Crown must consider the prosecution based on the available admissible evidence. Crown counsel may need to consider witness credibility when assessing whether the prosecution standard continues to be met, while recognizing that the ultimate assessment of evidence belongs to the court.

A changed statement may have a major effect if the witness provides essential evidence about a disputed event. In another case, however, photographs, video, police observations, digital communications, other witnesses, or other admissible evidence may remain available.

This is why statements such as “the witness took it back, so the charges have to disappear” can be misleading.

A witness or complainant does not personally control the prosecution. A change in their account can affect the strength of the evidence, but it does not by itself determine what happens next.

What Does It Mean for a Witness to “Change Their Story”?

The phrase can describe several different situations. They should not all be treated as legally identical.

A witness might:

  • Clarify an earlier statement. They may explain something that was unclear without changing the substance of the allegation.
  • Change one part of the account. A detail such as a time, location, sequence, or description may differ while the central allegation remains the same.
  • Give inconsistent versions. Two accounts may contain details that are difficult or impossible to reconcile.
  • Retract part of an allegation. The witness may withdraw a specific statement while maintaining other parts of the account.
  • Recant the accusation. The witness may substantially reverse or withdraw an earlier allegation.
  • Say the earlier statement was inaccurate or false. This creates a direct issue about why the accounts differ and which evidence, if any, should be accepted.

The defence should therefore look beyond the simple claim that a witness “changed their story.” The important questions are what changed, when it changed, why it changed, and whether the difference relates to a material issue in the case.

Why Does the Size of the Inconsistency Matter?

Not every inconsistency has the same evidentiary significance.

Suppose a witness first says an incident happened at approximately 9:00 p.m. and later says it may have been closer to 9:15 p.m. That difference could be relatively minor, depending on the case.

Now suppose the witness originally identifies one person as being present but later says that person was not there. If identity or presence is central to the allegation, that change may require much closer examination.

The same principle can apply to differences involving:

  • who performed an alleged act;
  • what was said;
  • where the event occurred;
  • the sequence of events;
  • whether force or threats were allegedly used;
  • communications before or after the incident; or
  • another fact central to an element the Crown must prove.

The defence may also examine whether the witness has a reasonable explanation for the change. An inconsistency is therefore something to investigate and test, not an automatic finding that the witness is dishonest.

Why Might a Witness Give Different Versions of the Same Event?

People do not always describe an event in exactly the same way every time they discuss it.

A witness may remember another detail later. A question may have been misunderstood. A person may describe an event differently when speaking to police than when answering detailed questions months later.

In other situations, a later statement may genuinely contradict something important in the original account.

The role of defence counsel is not simply to count differences. It is to determine whether the differences affect the credibility or reliability of evidence that matters to the criminal charge.

Does an Inconsistent Statement Mean the Witness Is Lying?

No. An inconsistency does not automatically establish dishonesty.

There may be different explanations for why two accounts do not match. Memory can be imperfect. Details may be recalled differently over time. The wording or context of earlier questioning can also matter.

On the other hand, some inconsistencies may be difficult to explain, particularly when they concern facts central to the allegation.

A Calgary criminal defence lawyer may therefore examine questions such as:

  • Was the earlier statement clear and detailed?
  • Was the witness asked about the same issue both times?
  • How much time passed between the statements?
  • Did the witness add new facts or directly contradict earlier facts?
  • Has the version changed more than once?
  • Does objective evidence support one version over another?
  • Did the witness provide an explanation for the difference?

This analysis helps distinguish an ordinary difference in recollection from a potentially significant evidentiary problem.

What Is the Difference Between Credibility and Reliability?

The two concepts are related, but they are not identical.

Credibility generally concerns whether the witness’s evidence should be believed. It can involve questions about honesty, consistency, explanations, and the overall way the evidence fits with the case.

Reliability focuses more closely on whether the evidence is accurate and dependable.

A witness may sincerely believe what they are saying but still be mistaken. For example, a person might honestly identify someone they briefly saw in poor conditions but be wrong about the identification.

That evidence could raise a reliability issue even if the witness is not deliberately lying.

Canadian courts treat reliability as an important concern when considering evidence, including situations involving prior inconsistent statements.

For defence purposes, this distinction matters. The question may not always be, “Is this witness lying?” It may instead be, “Can this evidence safely be relied upon?”

When Does a Changed Detail Become Material?

A change becomes more important when it relates directly to an issue the Crown must prove.

Defence counsel may consider:

  • whether the change concerns the identity of the accused;
  • whether it changes what the accused allegedly did;
  • whether important words, threats, or actions were added later;
  • whether the timing or location materially changed;
  • whether the new account conflicts with physical or digital evidence;
  • whether information disappeared from later versions; and
  • whether the changed detail affects another important part of the Crown’s theory.

Consider a simple example.

A witness tells police that a person wore a black jacket but later remembers the jacket as dark blue. Depending on the circumstances, that may have little impact.

If the same witness initially says they saw the accused commit the alleged act but later says they did not actually see what happened, the difference may be far more significant.

The evidentiary impact depends on the facts of the particular case. One contradiction does not automatically destroy the prosecution, just as a plausible explanation does not automatically remove every concern.

Can Earlier Police Statements Still Matter If the Witness Gives a Different Version?

Yes. An earlier police statement does not simply cease to exist because a witness later changes, retracts, or clarifies their account.

Earlier statements may become important when lawyers compare what the witness previously said with what the witness later says. Canadian evidence legislation specifically permits cross-examination about certain previous statements relevant to the case.

However, there is an important distinction.

Using an earlier statement to show that a witness previously said something different is not necessarily the same as using that statement as proof that the earlier version is true. Whether a prior statement can be used for a particular evidentiary purpose depends on the circumstances and applicable evidence law. The Supreme Court of Canada has emphasized reliability concerns when prior inconsistent statements are offered as hearsay evidence.

Does an Earlier Calgary Police Statement Disappear After a Witness Changes It?

No.

Suppose a witness gives Calgary police a recorded statement shortly after an alleged offence. Several weeks later, the witness provides a supplemental statement containing materially different information.

Both accounts may need to be examined.

Defence counsel may compare:

  • what the witness originally reported;
  • what was added later;
  • what was removed or changed;
  • whether the witness explained the difference;
  • when each change occurred; and
  • whether independent evidence supports or contradicts either account.

Disclosure is an important part of that process. Crown disclosure obligations extend to relevant material in the prosecution’s possession, including information that may assist the accused. Disclosure is also an ongoing responsibility as relevant information develops.

A later statement can therefore be important even if the trial is still months away.

What Is a Prior Inconsistent Statement?

A prior inconsistent statement is an earlier statement by a witness that conflicts in a meaningful way with evidence the witness later gives about the same subject.

For example:

  • Police statement: “I saw the accused strike him.”
  • Later testimony: “I did not actually see who struck him.”

That is more than a minor wording difference. The two versions concern a central factual issue.

Section 10 of the Canada Evidence Act permits a witness to be cross-examined about previous statements made in writing, reduced to writing, or recorded by audio, video, or other means when they relate to the subject matter of the case. The provision also sets requirements where the statement is being used to contradict the witness.

In practical terms, defence counsel may use an earlier account to ask the witness why their present evidence differs.

The significance will depend on factors such as:

  • how clear the earlier statement was;
  • whether the witness accepts making it;
  • how substantial the contradiction is;
  • whether an explanation is offered;
  • whether other evidence supports either version; and
  • whether the difference relates to a central allegation.

Can an Earlier Witness Statement Be Used at Trial?

Potentially, but not always in the same way.

A previous statement may be relevant to cross-examination and to assessing whether the witness’s trial evidence is consistent and dependable. Canadian law expressly provides a mechanism for cross-examining witnesses about relevant previous statements.

That does not mean every earlier statement automatically becomes proof of everything contained in it.

If a party seeks to use an earlier out-of-court statement for the truth of its contents, additional evidentiary rules may become relevant. The admissibility of hearsay evidence, including some prior inconsistent statements, is a question of law and can involve an assessment of necessity and reliability.

For an accused person, the practical point is straightforward: do not assume either the original statement or the changed statement will simply be ignored.

Both may require careful legal analysis.

How Can Disclosure Reveal That a Witness’s Story Has Changed?

A Calgary criminal defence lawyer can review disclosure to build a timeline of the witness’s evolving account.

That review may include:

  • initial police statements;
  • supplemental statements;
  • audio or video-recorded interviews;
  • officer notes;
  • 911 recordings;
  • text messages;
  • emails and other digital communications;
  • photographs;
  • surveillance or other video;
  • subsequent witness interviews; and
  • other relevant Crown disclosure.

The lawyer can then compare the evidence chronologically.

A useful analysis may look like this:

Earlier account → later account → explanation for change → supporting or contradictory evidence → effect on defence strategy

For example, the first police statement may contain one sequence of events. A later interview may add a significant allegation. Text messages sent immediately after the incident might then provide another source against which both versions can be tested.

The purpose is not to assume that the newest version is false or that the oldest version must be correct. It is to determine whether the development of the account creates a meaningful issue regarding accuracy, credibility, reliability, or the Crown’s ability to prove the allegation.

Careful disclosure review can be particularly important before criminal trial preparation, because a seemingly small difference may become more significant when it is compared with recordings, messages, police notes, or other evidence.

Does a Changed Witness Statement Mean the Crown Will Drop the Charges?

No. A changed or recanted witness statement does not automatically mean criminal charges will be withdrawn.

In Alberta, the decision to continue or discontinue a prosecution belongs to the Crown prosecutor, not to the complainant or another witness. Alberta Crown prosecution guidance specifically addresses the decision to prosecute and discontinue proceedings as a prosecutorial responsibility.

A major change in a witness’s account can still be important. It may cause the Crown to reconsider the strength of its case, particularly when the witness provides evidence essential to proving the allegation.

However, the Crown must look at the available case as a whole rather than treating one changed statement as automatically decisive.

Who Decides Whether Criminal Charges Continue?

A witness cannot personally “drop charges.”

Once a criminal prosecution is underway, the Crown prosecutor determines whether the prosecution should continue based on the applicable prosecution standard and the available evidence.

That distinction is important when a complainant says:

  • “I don’t want to proceed.”
  • “I want to take back my statement.”
  • “I exaggerated what happened.”
  • “My first statement was incorrect.”
  • “I don’t want to testify.”

Those statements may affect the Crown’s assessment, but they do not automatically terminate the criminal proceeding.

The Crown may consider questions such as:

  • How important is the witness to proving the charge?
  • What exactly changed?
  • Is the new version consistent with other evidence?
  • Is there an explanation for the change?
  • Are there independent witnesses?
  • Is there video, audio, physical, documentary, or digital evidence?
  • Can the prosecution still prove the charge despite the changed account?

A substantial recantation can weaken a prosecution in some cases. In others, the Crown may conclude that sufficient evidence remains to proceed.

Can the Prosecution Continue If the Main Witness Changes Their Account?

Potentially, yes.

A criminal case may involve much more than one witness statement. Depending on the allegations, other evidence might include:

  • surveillance or cellphone video;
  • photographs;
  • 911 recordings;
  • police observations;
  • statements from other witnesses;
  • text messages;
  • emails;
  • social media communications;
  • medical or forensic evidence, where relevant;
  • physical exhibits; or
  • other admissible evidence.

For example, suppose a witness initially reports seeing an assault but later says they are no longer certain who struck the complainant.

That change could create an important identification issue. If clear video independently records the event, however, the Crown’s case may not depend entirely on the changed eyewitness account.

The opposite may also be true. Where a prosecution depends heavily on one witness and that witness materially changes a central part of the allegation, the evidentiary impact may be much greater.

There is no single rule that applies to every changed witness statement.

What If the Witness Refuses to Cooperate or Testify?

A witness becoming unwilling to participate does not automatically cancel the prosecution.

Prosecutors may have to assess why the witness is unwilling, what evidence remains available, and whether the prosecution standard continues to be met. Federal prosecution guidance similarly recognizes that a witness’s unwillingness to testify can affect the assessment while not creating an automatic result in every case.

Depending on the circumstances, a person may also be legally required to attend court as a witness if properly compelled to do so.

An accused person should therefore not assume that a case has ended merely because someone says they no longer want to testify.

The proper question is: What evidence can the Crown lawfully present if the case proceeds?

That is something defence counsel should assess from the disclosure and the circumstances of the prosecution.

What If the Witness Gives Different Evidence at Trial?

A witness may arrive at court and give evidence that differs from an earlier police statement.

When that happens, lawyers may examine the difference directly.

The Canada Evidence Act permits cross-examination of a witness concerning certain previous statements relevant to the case. It also contains procedures for confronting a witness with a prior statement that is being used to contradict their testimony.

Defence counsel might ask:

  • Did you make this earlier statement?
  • When did you make it?
  • Was it recorded?
  • Were you describing the same incident?
  • Why is your evidence different today?
  • Which account is accurate?
  • Why was an important detail included in one version but omitted from another?

The answer may affect how the court evaluates the evidence.

However, an inconsistency does not automatically mean the witness should be rejected entirely. Its importance depends on the subject of the contradiction, the explanation, and the rest of the evidence.

What May Happen After a Witness Materially Changes Their Account?

Every Calgary criminal case develops differently, but a changed statement may lead to a process such as the following:

  1. The witness provides a new or changed account.
    This might occur through police, the Crown, another interview, or later testimony.
  2. Police or the Crown receive the new information.
    The change may be reviewed to determine what differs from the earlier version.
  3. The significance of the change is assessed.
    A minor correction may have little impact. A contradiction involving a central allegation may require closer review.
  4. Relevant information is provided through disclosure where required.
    Disclosure obligations continue as relevant information becomes available.
  5. Defence counsel compares the accounts.
    The lawyer may create a detailed chronology showing when allegations were added, removed, clarified, or contradicted.
  6. The Crown reassesses the prosecution where necessary.
    A major evidentiary development may affect how prosecutors evaluate whether the case should continue.
  7. Defence counsel adjusts the strategy.
    The change may affect cross-examination, negotiations with the Crown, evidentiary arguments, or overall trial preparation.
  8. If the case proceeds to trial, the court evaluates the evidence.
    The judge or jury, depending on the proceeding, assesses the admissible evidence and determines whether the Crown has proved guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

This is not a guaranteed sequence. Some steps may occur differently or may not be necessary in a particular case.

Can One Major Inconsistency Create Reasonable Doubt?

It can potentially contribute to reasonable doubt, especially when the contradiction concerns evidence central to the prosecution.

For example, there may be an important difference between:

  • being uncertain whether an event happened at 8:15 or 8:30 p.m.; and
  • first saying the accused committed an act and later saying the witness never actually saw who committed it.

The second inconsistency may have much greater significance.

Defence counsel may consider:

  • whether the inconsistency concerns an essential element of the offence;
  • how clearly the witness gave each version;
  • whether the witness can explain the change;
  • whether independent evidence supports one account;
  • whether multiple important changes occurred; and
  • whether other weaknesses exist in the Crown’s case.

A criminal defence lawyer should not assume that one contradiction guarantees an acquittal. The issue is whether the evidence, considered as a whole, leaves the court with a reasonable doubt.

What Should an Accused Person Do and Avoid After a Witness Changes Their Account?

Learning that a witness has changed or withdrawn an allegation can appear encouraging to an accused person.

It can also create serious risks if the accused responds improperly.

The safest approach is generally to provide the information to defence counsel, preserve relevant evidence, and continue complying strictly with every release condition.

Should the Accused Contact a Witness Who Wants to Change Their Statement?

An accused person should not attempt to persuade, pressure, threaten, coach, or otherwise influence a witness concerning their evidence.

This is especially important where a bail or release order prohibits communication.

Under the Criminal Code, release conditions can include a requirement that an accused abstain from communicating directly or indirectly with a victim, witness, or other named person.

Even where the witness contacts the accused first, that does not necessarily give the accused permission to respond if a court order prohibits communication.

Instead, the accused should tell their lawyer what happened.

Defence counsel can determine the appropriate legal way to deal with the development.

Does a Changed Story Cancel a Bail or No-Contact Condition?

No.

A witness changing their statement, wanting contact, or saying they no longer support the prosecution does not automatically cancel a no-contact condition.

Release conditions remain legally binding until they expire or are properly changed through the legal process. The Criminal Code provides mechanisms for varying certain release orders, including variation by written consent in circumstances covered by section 519.1.

That means an accused should not think:

“The witness has taken back the allegation, so the no-contact order no longer matters.”

That assumption can create additional legal problems.

If circumstances have genuinely changed, defence counsel can advise whether a variation should be sought.

Until then, the existing order should be followed according to its actual wording.

Can Someone Else Contact the Witness for the Accused?

Using another person can still create problems.

A release condition may prohibit both direct and indirect communication with a named witness. Section 515 of the Criminal Code expressly contemplates conditions restricting direct or indirect communication.

An accused should therefore be cautious about asking:

  • a friend to deliver a message;
  • a relative to speak with the witness;
  • a mutual acquaintance to ask the witness to change their evidence;
  • someone to contact the witness through social media; or
  • another person to arrange a meeting.

Whether particular conduct breaches a condition depends on the wording of the order and the circumstances.

The safer course is to speak with defence counsel before taking any action involving the witness.

  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 12
  • Go to Next Page »

Get a Free Consultation With a Certified Criminal Lawyer Get Started

Akram Law

About Us

Khalid Akram, a criminal defence lawyer in Calgary, offers expert representation for a range of legal issues.

Calgary Office

Akram Law, #280, 700 - 6th Avenue SW, Calgary, AB T2P 0T8
Email: info@akramlaw.com
Phone: 403-774–9529
  • Contact Us
  • Get Started
  • About Us
  • Blog

Practice Areas

  • Assault Lawyer
  • Impaired Driving Lawyer
  • Sexual Assault Lawyer
  • Bail Hearing Lawyer
  • Theft & Fraud Offences Lawyer
  • Drug Offence Lawyer

Areas We Serve

  • Calgary
  • Chestermere
  • Okotoks
  • Cochrane
  • Irricana
  • Airdrie
  • Crossfield
© 2024-2026 Akram Law. All Rights Reserved.